NOVEMBER 17, 2026
Nobody Can Guarantee a Headline
Nevindee Amarasinghe

A few months ago, a prospective client slid a proposal across my desk and asked, quite politely, why ours cost more than the one next to it. The other agency promised 30 published articles and 30 backlinks in 2 Weeks. Guaranteed. Ours promised effort, strategy and honesty about what we couldn’t promise.
I understood the temptation. If I were buying PR for the first time, I’d have circled the guarantee too.
It took me back to my early years in this industry, when I once spent an entire week chasing a single business editor. I called, emailed and rewrote my pitch three times. In the end, what got the story across the line was a conversation. I’d read his column, noticed what he cared about, and offered him an angle that served his readers, not my client. That story ran, and I couldn’t have promised it on day one.
That is the part of PR no package can capture. A journalist isn’t a distribution channel. They are a person with an editor, a deadline, a skeptical eye and a reputation to protect. Earning their attention takes research, relationships, good writing and timing. Sometimes it also takes the grace to hear “not this time” and come back with something better.
What’s being sold instead
Lately, “guaranteed coverage” has become a product. The method is rarely hidden: generate content at scale, blast it to as many inboxes as possible, and let the numbers do the work. Send enough emails and something will stick, and a link will appear somewhere. The client gets a report full of placements and the agency gets to call it a win.
But look at what’s missing: no story judgment, no relationship, no consideration of whether the coverage builds the client’s credibility or just fills a spreadsheet. That is mass mailing with a better sales pitch, not public relations.
The timing makes it more dangerous. Brands now understand that credible media coverage shapes how they appear in search and in AI-generated answers. That’s good news for our profession, because earned media carries weight precisely because someone independent decided it was worth publishing. Volume can’t replicate that. The moment coverage becomes a purchased guarantee, it loses the very thing that made it valuable.
Why this matters in a market like ours
Sri Lanka’s media community is small and well connected. Editors remember who respects their time and who spams them. One careless, irrelevant pitch can cost an agency a door that took years to open. Reputation is the real currency here, and it compounds in both directions.
There’s also the next generation to think about. A young professional trained to chase volume learns to send, not to listen. They never learn to write a pitch worth reading, to build trust with a reporter, or to tell a client honestly what is and isn’t realistic. We risk raising a generation who think PR is a numbers game.
What we owe our clients
Honest PR doesn’t promise outcomes. It promises craft and transparency: a clear strategy, the right audiences, strong storytelling, and straight talk when the story isn’t strong enough yet. It means reporting on what actually moved the needle, not just how many links appeared.
That conversation is harder to win in a sales meeting. “We can’t guarantee it, but here’s how we’ll earn it” is a tougher pitch than “40 articles, guaranteed.” But it is the only one that’s true.
We can’t stop others from selling guarantees. We can refuse to call it PR, and we can say so whenever we find ourselves in the same room. That client, by the way, is still weighing both proposals. I’d rather lose a pitch than win it with a promise I can’t keep.
Want the Full Playbook?
Our Crisis Response framework is reserved for partners facing systemic reputation risks.
Enquire Today →Want the Full Playbook?
Our Crisis Response framework is reserved for partners facing systemic reputation risks.
Enquire Today →